BenchLeader

Claude Opus 4.8 vs Gemini 4 Carbon

Full profiles: Claude Opus 4.8 (Anthropic) and Gemini 4 Carbon (Google): every benchmark, price and rank.

Updated · Data from 9 sources

As of 10 Nov 2026, Gemini 4 Carbon is ahead of Claude Opus 4.8 on quality (68.5 vs 60.5 on the BenchLeader Index), and Gemini 4 Carbon is 1.3× cheaper at $8.00 vs $10.00 per 1M tokens blended. Gemini 4 Carbon leads in every category we measure both in.

Key facts (as of 10 Nov 2026)

  • Claude Opus 4.8 scores 60.5 on the BenchLeader Index and Gemini 4 Carbon scores 68.5 (BenchLeader, 10 Nov 2026).
  • Claude Opus 4.8 costs $10.00 per 1M tokens blended (list price, 10 Nov 2026).
  • Gemini 4 Carbon costs $8.00 per 1M tokens blended (list price, 10 Nov 2026).
  • Of the 7 benchmarks both models have, Gemini 4 Carbon leads 7 (BenchLeader, 10 Nov 2026).
  • On Arena WebDev, Claude Opus 4.8 is rated 1555 and Gemini 4 Carbon 1768 (LMArena, as published by 10 Nov 2026).

Which to pick for…

The pick's numbers come first. Category scores on the BenchLeader scale (50 is the average model, 15 points one standard deviation). High confidence means a lead of half a standard deviation or more; under one point is called either.

Use casePickWhyConfidence
CodingGemini 4 Carbon75 vs 61 category score; Arena WebDev 1768 vs 1555High
ReasoningGemini 4 Carbon77 vs 60 category score; Arena Hard Prompts 1546 vs 1513High
Chat quality (human preference)Gemini 4 Carbon73 vs 67 on Arena votesMedium
Lowest costGemini 4 Carbon$8.00 vs $10.00 per 1M blended; agentic coding session $0.320 vs $0.400–
Fastest first answerClaude Opus 4.80.8 s (Claude Opus 4.8 (high)) vs 66.8 s (Gemini 4 Carbon (high)) to the first answer token–
High volume on a budgetNeither flagshipA smaller model is usually the better fit: Cheapest good LLMs, Fastest LLMs–

Key differences

  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high) leads on quality: 68.5 vs 60.5.
  • Claude Opus 4.8 (high) is stronger in maths, multimodal.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high) is stronger in coding, human preference, reasoning, agents & tools, knowledge, long context.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high) is 1.3× cheaper ($8.00 vs $10.00 per 1M blended).

At a glance

SpecClaude Opus 4.8Gemini 4 Carbon
DeveloperAnthropicGoogle
Released28 May 202628 Oct 2026
Context window (tokens)1,000,0001,048,576
Compared atClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)
Open weightsNoNo
Price in / out / cached input per 1M$5.00 / $25.00 / $0.500$4.00 / $20.00 / $0.100

Category by category

Category scores on the BenchLeader scale: 50 is the average evaluated model, 15 points is one standard deviation. A gap under one point is called level.

CategoryClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)Leader
Reasoning60.076.9Gemini 4 Carbon
Coding61.374.5Gemini 4 Carbon
Agents & tools–78.2not comparable
Maths67.5–not comparable
Knowledge–74.4not comparable
Human preference67.272.6Gemini 4 Carbon
Multimodal64.0–not comparable
Long context–64.3not comparable

On one chart

Each domain on the index's own scale, where 50 is an average model. Click a domain to see the benchmarks behind it. Pick up to 5 models from the list.

2550 avg75ReasoningCodingHumanpreferenceClaude Opus 4.8, Reasoning: 60.0Claude Opus 4.8, Coding: 61.3Claude Opus 4.8, Human preference: 67.2Gemini 4 Carbon, Reasoning: 76.9Gemini 4 Carbon, Coding: 74.5Gemini 4 Carbon, Human preference: 72.6

Not drawn, measured for fewer than two of these models: Agents & tools, Maths, Knowledge, Instruction following, Long context, Multimodal.

ModelIndex

Where sources disagree

Across the 7 benchmarks both have, Claude Opus 4.8 leads 0, Gemini 4 Carbon leads 7. Every overall index that rates both puts Gemini 4 Carbon ahead.

Overall indexClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)Leader
BenchLeader Index60.568.5Gemini 4 Carbon
Arena Text14821526Gemini 4 Carbon

Each publisher runs its own tasks, harnesses and effort settings, so their overall verdicts can differ; BenchLeader reconciles them on one scale. † measured at another effort setting of the same model (the publisher did not test the one compared here).

Price, speed and latency

List prices blended at three input tokens per output token. Per-task prices use the token counts on the methodology page. Cost, tokens and time per benchmark task are measured: Artificial Analysis’ averages over its whole Intelligence Index run.

MeasureClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)
Blended price per 1M tokens$10.00$8.00
Input / output per 1M$5.00 / $25.00$4.00 / $20.00
Cached input per 1M$0.500$0.100
Price per task: chat reply$0.0095$0.0076
Price per task: summarize a 30-page report$0.075$0.060
Price per task: code edit$0.068$0.054
Price per task: agentic coding session$0.400$0.320
Price per task: structured extraction$0.015$0.012
Agentic coding session, input mostly cached$0.198$0.144
Cost per benchmark task (AA Index)–$7.76
Output tokens per task (AA Index)–123k
Of which reasoning–72k
Time per task (AA Index)–26 min
Output speed69 tok/s80 tok/s
Time to first answer0.8 s66.8 s
Time to a complete answer–156.1 s

Each model is compared at its best-ranked reasoning-effort setting. Claude Opus 4.8 (high) scores 60.5 and takes 1 s to its first answer token; Claude Opus 4.8 (max) scores 60.1 in 35 s, Claude Opus 4.8 scores 60.1 in 1 s. Gemini 4 Carbon (high) scores 68.5 and takes 67 s to its first answer token; Gemini 4 Carbon (medium) scores 64.1 in 23 s. Higher effort means more thinking before the answer: better scores, longer waits and more tokens billed. How reasoning effort changes scores and cost.

Every benchmark

139 benchmarks, grouped by category; each name links to the board and its leaders. † measured at another effort setting of the same model, shown for reference and not counted as a win.

MetricPublisherClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)
BenchLeader IndexBenchLeader60.568.5
Coding scoreBenchLeader61.374.5
Human preference scoreBenchLeader67.272.6
Maths scoreBenchLeader67.5–
Multimodal scoreBenchLeader64.0–
Reasoning scoreBenchLeader60.076.9
Agents & tools scoreBenchLeader–78.2
Knowledge scoreBenchLeader–74.4
Long context scoreBenchLeader–64.3
Blended price $/MBenchLeader$10.00$8.00
Output speedBenchLeader69 tok/s80 tok/s
Time to first answerBenchLeader0.8 s66.8 s
Context windowBenchLeader1,000,000 tokens1,048,576 tokens
Reasoning
GPQA DiamondEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub91.0%†–
SimpleBenchSimpleBench64.8%†–
Arena Hard PromptsArena (LMArena)15131546
LiveBench 1.0 ReasoningLiveBench89.2%†–
GPQA Diamond (AA)Artificial Analysis92.0%†–
Humanity's Last Exam (AA)Artificial Analysis48.7%†–
HLE-Diamond (AA)Artificial Analysis–69.1%
GPQA Diamond (Vals)Vals AI92.4%†–
EnigmaEvalScale AI SEAL23.5%†–
Kagi LLM BenchmarkKagi LLM Benchmark88.8%†–
ARC-AGI-1ARC Prize92.0%–
ARC-AGI-2ARC Prize72.1%–
ARC-AGI-3ARC Prize1.5%–
CritPtArtificial Analysis20.9%†–
CritPt v2 hard subset (AA)Artificial Analysis–69.0%
Chess PuzzlesEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub52.0%†–
Mystery Game PuzzlesEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub36.0%†–
LMCAEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub57.5%†–
DTBenchEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub94.9%†–
ForecastBenchForecastBench62.4%†–
BTF-3Epoch AI Benchmarking Hub14.0%–
Coding
SciCodeSciCode53.5%†64.2%
WeirdMLWeirdML70.5%†–
FrontierCodeCognition46.5%†–
GSO-BenchGSO-Bench47.1%†–
Show all 139 benchmarks
MetricPublisherClaude Opus 4.8 (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)
Coding
Arena CodingArena (LMArena)15331567
Arena WebDevArena (LMArena)15551768
LiveBench 1.0 CodingLiveBench81.8%†–
SciCode (AA)Artificial Analysis54.4%†–
LiveCodeBenchVals AI87.8%†–
SWE-bench (Vals)Vals AI88.6%†–
Code MigrationVals AI47.3%†–
ProgramBenchVals AI1.0%†–
Vibe Code Bench v1.1Vals AI82.7%†89.1%
SWE Atlas: Codebase QnAScale AI SEAL57.3%†–
SWE Atlas: RefactoringScale AI SEAL46.7%†–
SWE Atlas: Test WritingScale AI SEAL49.6%†–
Surface Evolver BenchEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub87.5%–
DeepSWE v1.1Epoch AI Benchmarking Hub51.8%–
ALE-BenchEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub1563.8–
FrontierSWEEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub–61.2%
Terminal-Bench 4.0 (AA)Artificial Analysis21.7%†65.2%
Terminal-Bench 2.1 (AA)Artificial Analysis84.6%†–
GameBench 2 OverallDuelLab GameBench 249.6†–
GameBench 2 by reasoning settingDuelLab GameBench 245.4†–
Design Arena WebsiteDesign Arena1255†–
FrontierCode 2.0 (AA)Artificial Analysis–40.6%
Agents & tools
Terminal-BenchTerminal-Bench23.6%†–
OSWorld-Verified 2.0OSWorld20.6%†–
Remote Labor IndexScale AI / CAIS8.3%†–
APEX-AgentsMercor48.9%†84.2%†
Arena AgentArena (LMArena)–16.6
LiveBench Agentic CodingLiveBench50.5%†–
Terminal-Bench HardArtificial Analysis58.3%†–
τ²-Bench Telecom (AA)Artificial Analysis94.4%†–
Terminal-Bench 2.1 (Vals)Vals AI71.9%†–
MCP AtlasScale AI SEAL82.2%†–
HiL-BenchScale AI SEAL35.3%†–
τ³-bench Bankingτ²-bench39.7%†–
GDPval-AA v2.1Artificial Analysis–1733
τ³-Banking (AA)Artificial Analysis34.2%†–
Analyst Agent (AA)Artificial Analysis45.0%†–
Finance Agent v2Vals AI53.9%†–
Finance Agent v2.1Vals AI–67.2%
Harvey's Legal Agent Benchmark v1.1Vals AI–17.5%
Harvey's Legal Agent Benchmark v1Vals AI9.6%†–
Legal Research BenchVals AI43.8%†55.8%
SkillsBenchVals AI59.2%†–
Tax Agent BenchVals AI30.0%†51.8%
Terminal-Bench 2.0 (Vals)Vals AI70.0%†–
Terminal-Bench 4.0 (Vals)Vals AI23.2%†63.1%
Terminal-Bench ScienceVals AI4.3%†–
Time Horizon Index: KSPVals AI11.8%†–
Arena SearchArena (LMArena)1194†–
DeepResearch BenchDeepResearch Bench50.2%–
PostTrainBenchEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub33.8%–
GBAEvalEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub70.9%†–
Vending-Bench 2Andon Labs5787.4†16484.2†
AutomationBenchArtificial Analysis45.6%†77.8%
GDP.pdf (AA)Artificial Analysis22.8%†28.4%
EnterpriseOps-GymArtificial Analysis44.0%†–
AA-Briefcase v1.1Artificial Analysis1320†1611
GDPxGDPx by SemiAnalysis–10.9%
Design Arena AgenticDesign Arena1218†–
Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 (AA)Artificial Analysis–64.8%
FACTS SearchGoogle–94.4%†
Maths
FrontierMath Tiers 1–3Epoch AI Benchmarking Hub80.0%†–
FrontierMath Tier 4Epoch AI Benchmarking Hub56.1%†–
OTIS Mock AIMEEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub98.3%†–
ProofBenchVals AI69.0%†–
LiveBench MathematicsLiveBench94.3%†–
AIME 2026MathArena100.0%†–
HMMT February 2026MathArena95.5%†–
MathArena ApexMathArena81.3%†–
Arena MathsArena (LMArena)1492–
Knowledge
SimpleQA VerifiedEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub53.0%†–
LiveBench 1.0 Data AnalysisLiveBench66.0%†–
AA-Omniscience v1.1Artificial Analysis–53.5
MMLU-ProVals AI89.6%†–
LegalBenchVals AI83.6%†–
CorpFinVals AI66.7%†–
TaxEvalVals AI75.6%†–
Excel Modeling BenchmarkVals AI69.4%†–
Excel Modeling Benchmark v1.1Vals AI–76.5%
MedCodeVals AI53.2%†–
MedScribeVals AI85.8%†–
Public Benefits Bench v1.1Vals AI68.1%†–
DrugDiscoveryBenchScale AI SEAL46.8%†–
EBR-benchEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub28.6%†–
GDP.pdfEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub24.0%†–
AA-Omniscience v1.1: accuracyArtificial Analysis–58.3%
AA-Omniscience v1.1: non-hallucinationArtificial Analysis–88.6%
Instruction following
LiveBench LanguageLiveBench79.7%†–
LiveBench Instruction FollowingLiveBench72.0%†–
IFBenchArtificial Analysis62.2%†–
Arena Instruction FollowingArena (LMArena)14921525
Human preference
Arena TextArena (LMArena)14821526
EQ-Bench 4EQ-Bench1268†–
Arena Creative WritingArena (LMArena)14701515
Arena Multi-turnArena (LMArena)14971564
Arena Longer QueriesArena (LMArena)15031537
Multimodal
Arena VisionArena (LMArena)1295–
MMMU-ProArtificial Analysis–89.3%†
MMMU-Pro (Vals)Vals AI86.6%†–
MortgageTaxVals AI69.9%†–
Blueprint-Bench 2Epoch AI Benchmarking Hub14.5%†58.6%†
Long context
AA-LCR v1.1Artificial Analysis77.7%†79.3%
Arena DocumentArena (LMArena)1485–
MLCRArtificial Analysis19.4%†–
Composite
Epoch Capabilities IndexEpoch AI Benchmarking Hub159.9†–
LiveBench 1.0LiveBench76.2%†–
AA Intelligence Index v5.0Artificial Analysis–60.0
AA Intelligence Index v4.3.2Artificial Analysis41.8†–
AA Progress Index v1Artificial Analysis318.4†350.8
Vals IndexVals AI–70.5
Vals Finance IndexVals AI–67.0%
Vals RSI IndexVals AI24.0%†27.7%
Vals Multimodal IndexVals AI70.9%†–
Safety & honesty
FORTRESSScale AI SEAL18.2%†–

Data as of 2026-11-10. Best configuration of each model; every score links to its source on the model pages.

DuelLab GameBench 2, release gb2-20261103-eaea31df94e6 (https://benchmarks.duellab.org/releases/gb2-20261103-eaea31df94e6/), CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). Scores mapped to BenchLeader model names; not endorsed by DuelLab.

What changed

  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 2 new results (FrontierSWE, Vals RSI Index).
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): BenchLeader Index 69.3 → 68.5.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): BenchLeader Index 68.8 → 69.3.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 1 score revision.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 2 score revisions.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 1 score revision.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 2 score revisions.
  • Gemini 4 Carbon (high): 1 score revision.
  • Claude Opus 4.8 (high): BenchLeader Index 61.1 → 60.6.
  • Claude Opus 4.8 (high): 1 score revision.

Rankings: Best LLM overall · Best LLM for coding · Best LLM for agents · Best cheap LLMs

Claude Opus 4.8 vs Gemini 4 Carbon: questions

Is Gemini 4 Carbon better than Claude Opus 4.8?
Gemini 4 Carbon (high) leads on quality: 68.5 vs 60.5. The BenchLeader Index combines every independent quality benchmark; Gemini 4 Carbon (high) is ahead overall as of 10 Nov 2026, but check the category scores for your use.
Claude Opus 4.8 vs Gemini 4 Carbon: which is cheaper, and will that change?
Gemini 4 Carbon is cheaper today: $8.00 against $10.00 per million tokens, blended at three input tokens per output token. No price change has been announced for either.
Is Claude Opus 4.8 or Gemini 4 Carbon better for coding?
Gemini 4 Carbon scores higher in coding (75 vs 61 on the category index, where 50 is average). On Arena WebDev, the top shared coding benchmark, it is 1555 for Claude Opus 4.8 against 1768 for Gemini 4 Carbon.
Which is faster, Claude Opus 4.8 or Gemini 4 Carbon?
Gemini 4 Carbon streams faster (80 vs 69 output tokens per second, Artificial Analysis 7-day median).
Which is better for long documents?
Both take about 1M tokens: Claude Opus 4.8 1,000,000, Gemini 4 Carbon 1,048,576.
More questions (3)
Which has lower latency?
Claude Opus 4.8 answers first: 0.8 s against 66.8 s to the first answer token, as Artificial Analysis measures it. Reasoning effort drives most of this: a higher setting thinks longer before it answers.
Do independent benchmarks agree on Claude Opus 4.8 vs Gemini 4 Carbon?
Across the 7 benchmarks both have, Claude Opus 4.8 leads 0, Gemini 4 Carbon leads 7. Every overall index that rates both puts Gemini 4 Carbon ahead.
When was Gemini 4 Carbon released?
Gemini 4 Carbon was released on 28 Oct 2026.